The Dance of Democracy - A Theory of Politics to Cure What Ails Us
In reflecting on how we defend and renew our democracies, I keep coming back to one thing. How do we disagree better. How do we hold different views without leaping to demonization of those differences. How do we keep community and connection while we sustain the absolutely inevitable diversity that any group of humans will have on how they see the world, and which direction they think everyone should take.
I think that core orientation, call it pluralism, is the beating heart of democracy. If you don’t have any respect and value for that diversity of perspective, I think you are, essentially, not a democrat. You might be an authoritarian who thinks only some ideas are right and should always rule regardless of what people think, or you might be a totalitarian who feels everyone should be forced to think the same way.
The large majority of us are genuine democrats. Yet so many people I meet espouse democratic ideals but then treat others in ways that don’t manifest them. To be clear, I don’t mean validating and endorsing all kinds of ideas. I mean respecting them, engaging them on their merits, respecting and connecting to the person making them, and not defaulting to power plays, silent treatment, deception, and different kinds of force to win arguments and win power. In so many communities, politics has stopped being a conversation and become combat. That’s exactly the world authoritarians live in, and want to drag us all into.
Maybe one reason for this is that I think we might all have a false model of politics in our heads that encourages combative tribalism. We have a sense of a fixed political spectrum, from left to right. We place ourselves on this spectrum where we believe good people are, grade the character of others based on how they are from us, and then fight for our tribe to win arguments and elections. For most of my activist friends, politics is a historic battle between good and evil, like Star Wars. It’s a seductive story, you get to be the hero, and it gives your life meaning.
But, I think, it’s bullshit.
There’s absolutely no basis in any reasonable assessment to conclude that any part of the political spectrum is either good or evil. There is blood on all hands, and great accomplishments on all sides.
Even more confusingly, the political spectrum is itself is largely bullshit. Human beings don’t neatly sort on a left right spectrum AT ALL. There are many axes on which humans disagree, and identify. For example, there is no correlation, in ANY country of the world, between being left or right wing on cultural issues and being left or right wing on economic issues. Culture and economics are separate axes of disagreement. As is whether you are pro or anti-establishment. Or for that matter how democratic or authoritarian you are!
So while our elites often do tend to sort neatly on a left/right spectrum, people, collectively, are a beautiful mess. But just saying that doesn’t seem to dislodge a very well worn Star Wars model that lives in the heads of our professional activists and politicians and tends towards polarization. So I’ve been thinking about what an alternative model might look like, and here’s what I came up with:

My brain immediately starts to try and see left and right in these roles, but they don’t map well at all. There are dreamers and builders and stewards and guardians on all sides. As there are zealots and bureaucrats and stonewallers and gatekeepers.
Dreamers take ideas out of wilderness and push them into the mainstream, where builders try to make them real in the world. Stewards make sure you don’t cause more harm than good with the changes you make, while Guardians fiercely defend what they feel must be protected.
Zealots push radical ideas without respect for the people they seek to change. Bureaucrats are what builders become when lose the plot and just go through motions, not trying to actually make the world a better place. Stewards become stonewallers when they resist all change, or Oligarchs when they protect their own interests. And Guardians can be a moral conscience of society or they can become inquisitors or gatekeepers, attacking and excluding those they deem impure.
My hope is that this kind of model might help us see our roles as valuable, and not the only valuable role. And see that the role we’re playing has a dark side just like others do. And when we see someone going over to the dark side, we might be able to call them back to their higher calling, even if it’s not the same as ours.
If we’re going to survive the disruptions that the coming decades are going to bring - to our economies, societies and environment - we’re going to need a healthy, high functioning, adaptive system of government. That doesn’t mean agreeing all the time - disagreements are exactly what make us adaptive - it means managing that diversity well in a way that keeps each of us at our best and the whole system working to get us where we need to go. Hope this model helps.


Comments